Send-Outs Getting Rejected

You send strong candidates. Few of them ever get an interview.

The short answer: When strong send-outs rarely turn into interviews, the hiring manager is usually screening against criteria you were never given.

Why it matters

Every send-out that doesn’t get an interview is sourcing, screening and writing that brings you no closer to a placement fee.

Few interviews means a thin pipeline, and a thin pipeline means the search drags on.

The client starts to judge you by your hit rate. Let it slide far enough and your candidates drop to the bottom of the pile, behind the other recruiters on the search.

What’s usually behind it

A send-out is the hiring manager’s first impression of your candidate, and you’re the one who shapes it. You get one chance to set it.

The hiring manager forms that impression by comparing what you sent to what they’re looking for. If that was never agreed with you, they’re screening against criteria you were never given: a must-have that isn’t in the job description, a dealbreaker nobody mentioned, a priority that outranks everything else.

Your send-out answers the job description. The hiring manager is reading for something else. Good candidates fall short of a bar you couldn’t see.

You’re being measured against a standard nobody wrote down.

Signs this is what’s happening

  • Most of your send-outs to this client never get an interview.
  • Candidates who meet everything in the job description still don’t get past the first look.
  • When you do get a reason, it names something the job description never asked for.
  • The few candidates who get interviews share something nobody told you to look for.

What you’re feeling

What’s causing it

Nobody agreed on what this hire needs to do.

See what’s really going on, and your options for fixing it for good.

Hiring Manager Intake

Other possible causes

Something else going on?

If this doesn’t sound like your search, tell us what’s happening. A real person reads every one.