Paraphrasing What Candidates Said
You tell the hiring manager what the candidate said. You’re not sure those were their words.
The short answer: When all you have is notes, every quote becomes your paraphrase. The hiring manager hears your version, not the candidate’s.
Why it matters
Hiring managers weigh what candidates say in their own words. Your paraphrase makes it sound like your opinion.
If your version drifts and the hiring manager hears something different in the interview, it’s your credibility that takes the hit.
And when someone asks “what exactly did they say?”, you don’t have an answer.
What’s usually behind it
Paraphrasing isn’t a bad habit. It’s what notes force you to do. You wrote down the gist, so the gist is all you can pass on.
Every retelling moves a little further from the original. Your notes compress it, the send-out smooths it, and the call with the hiring manager simplifies it again.
By the time it reaches the hiring manager, the candidate’s answer has been rewritten more than once, often by more than one person.
The hiring manager never hears the candidate. They hear the end of a game of telephone.
Signs this is what’s happening
- Your notes summarize the conversation instead of capturing what was actually said.
- Two people reading your notes would quote the candidate differently.
- Your send-outs say “the candidate mentioned” instead of quoting them.
- You hesitate when the hiring manager asks how the candidate put it.
What you’re feeling
What’s causing it
- Paraphrasing What Candidates Said
- Notes Missing the Details
- Taking Notes Instead of Listening
- Disputed Intake Notes
Your notes aren’t what they actually said.
See what’s really going on, and your options for fixing it for good.
Raw Call TranscriptsOther possible causes
- The candidate didn’t give you much to quote. They spoke in generalities, so there was nothing specific to pass on.
Something else going on?
If this doesn’t sound like your search, tell us what’s happening. A real person reads every one.